If you’re a Tampa business owner tired of SEO agencies overpromising and underdelivering, this report is for you.
Here’s the inside track — Tampa’s leading SEO agencies, featuring transparent pricing, real case studies, and proven results. No hype, just the facts you need to choose a partner that gets results.
Table of Contents
Quick Preview: Top Tampa SEO Agencies
Digital Neighbor: Kind, innovative, with hard-hitting measurable results
Tampa SEO Agency: Deep local knowledge, competitive audits, custom strategy
SEO Company Tampa: Performance-driven, technical optimization, link-building
Redblink: Award-winning full-service Tampa local SEO
WebFX: Tech-forward, scalable SEO, national reputation
Firestarter SEO: Conversion rate specialists, proven results
Straight North: Enterprise expertise, strategic approach
Best SEO Agency in Tampa
Digital Neighbor: Tampa’s Friendly, Data-Driven SEO Partner
Founded: About 2016
Location: Tampa, FL
Core Services: SEO, Content, Web Design, Local SEO, PPC, Analytics
Pricing: Custom plans average $1,000–$5,000/month
Digital Neighbor blends kindness and innovation, boasting measurable results, award-winning campaigns, and custom marketing for every business type. They’ve driven clients to 144K sessions, with 85% traffic increase and helped one eCommerce brand grow sales by 299%. Their local SEO strategies have helped law firms dominate local map pack searches across multiple locations.
Best for: Tampa area businesses who value hard data, local expertise, and personable client experience.
Tampa SEO Agency: The Local SEO Specialists
Founded: Not listed
Location: Tampa, FL
Core Services: SEO, Local SEO, Web Design, PPC, Reputation Management
Pricing: $900–$4,500/month; Custom packages available
Tampa SEO Agency delivers comprehensive SEO auditing, strategic planning, website optimization, local citations, map pack domination, and competitive tracking. Their client base runs from new startups to large enterprises—every project is custom-fitted for goals and ROI. Known for their local Tampa focus and high-touch service.
Best for: Businesses wanting aggressive growth in Tampa Bay, local market knowledge, and a personalized strategy.
SEO Company Tampa: Results & Performance at Scale
Founded: Not listed
Location: Tampa, FL
Core Services: SEO, Technical Optimization, Link-Building, Content Marketing
Pricing: $1,200–$4,000/month
SEO Company Tampa specializes in technical audits, white-hat link-building, on-page/off-page SEO, keyword research, and content creation. They combine competitive audits with ongoing optimization for predictable ROI and conversion growth.
Best for: Tampa businesses seeking value, transparency, and results-oriented campaigns.
Redblink: Full-Service SEO for Local Market Domination
Founded: 2015
Location: Tampa, FL
Core Services: SEO, Local SEO, Content, Web Design
Pricing: $850–$3,500/month
Redblink emphasizes transparency and reporting, focusing on organic growth, domain authority, and Google Maps Pack optimization. Their advanced entity SEO and usability testing support small brands and big enterprises alike.
Best for: Businesses seeking cost-effective, comprehensive local SEO strategies and reliable reporting.
WebFX: Tech-Forward Enterprise SEO
Founded: 1996
Location: National reach (Tampa office)
Core Services: SEO, PPC, Social Media, Web Design
Pricing: $1,200–$10,000+/month
WebFX brings scalable, AI-powered SEO campaigns and ROI-focused account management to businesses ready for enterprise-level digital growth in Tampa. Their proprietary tech stack and hands- on specialists deliver monthly reports and clear results.
Best for: Larger Tampa businesses or those needing complex, scalable SEO strategy.
Firestarter SEO: Conversion & Reputation Experts
Founded: 2012
Location: Tampa, FL
Core Services: SEO, CRO, Reputation Management, Local SEO
Pricing: $1,000–$4,000/month
Firestarter combines conversion rate optimization, technical SEO, content marketing, and local reviews management to deliver measurable improvements in visibility and lead generation. Their testimonials include doubled website visitors and 100% increase in conversion rates for Tampa area clients.
Best for: Companies in competitive verticals (home services, legal, retail, healthcare) needing both rankings and conversion improvements.
Straight North: Enterprise-Grade SEO Solutions
Founded: 1997
Location: National reputation, serves Tampa market
Core Services: SEO, PPC, Web Design
Pricing: $1,200–$6,000+/month
Straight North leverages extensive experience in complex SEO, PPC, and web development to drive client websites higher in rankings and conversions. Their strategic project management and proven results make them a favorite for enterprise and mid-market clients.
Best for: Companies wanting strategic, long-term SEO, advanced analytics, and enterprise support.
Tampa SEO Pricing Table
| Agency | Starting Price | Typical Range | Best For |
| Digital Neighbor | $1,000/mo | $1,000–$5,000 | Friendly, data-driven SEO |
| Tampa SEO Agency | $900/mo | $900–$4,500 | Local market dominance |
| SEO Company Tampa | $1,200/mo | $1,200–$4,000 | Conversion-focused SEO |
| Redblink | $850/mo | $850–$3,500 | Cost-effective local SEO |
| WebFX | $1,200/mo | $1,200–$10,000+ | Scalable, tech-driven SEO |
| Firestarter SEO | $1,000/mo | $1,000–$4,000 | Conversion specialists |
| Straight North | $1,200/mo | $1,200–$6,000+ | Enterprise-level SEO |
Red Flags to Watch For in Tampa
- Under-$500/month prices (almost always low-quality services)
- No case studies or real testimonials
- Outsourced work not performed locally
- Lack of transparent deliverables
- Pressure tactics for long-term contracts
- Vague reporting or little accountability
Best Practices for Choosing Your Tampa SEO Agency
Require transparent, monthly reporting
Verify local testimonials and case studies
Interview the SEO team directly
Start with month-to-month contracts
Prioritize agencies that track leads, conversions, and not just rankings
Step-by-Step Tampa SEO Success Formula
- Audit and optimize website and Google My Business
- Research Tampa-specific keywords and competitors
- Build targeted, conversion-driven content
- Develop local backlinks and citations
- Track traffic, rankings, and lead generation
- Adjust monthly; respond to Google updates
- Scale strategies for wider regional reach
Quick Takeaways
Most SEO packages in Tampa fall $850–$5,000/month
Local case studies and testimonials are required
Transparency and clear deliverables win
Conversion tracking beats “rankings only” focus
Start small, scale with trust
Conclusion
Don’t fall into the generic trap. Invest in Tampa agencies with real, local wins — demand accountability, and measure ROI beyond rankings. These agencies know Tampa’s market. Pick one aligned with your goals, maintain transparency, and scale with confidence.
FAQs
How much does SEO cost in Tampa?
Most businesses pay $850–$5,000 monthly. Enterprise packages and add-ons cost more.
How long for SEO to show results?
You’ll see traffic and conversion changes in 3–6 months for local campaigns, longer for complex targets.
Should I hire only local Tampa agencies?
Local experience matters. National agencies with Tampa case studies can also work.
What’s the biggest SEO mistake?
Picking the lowest-priced agency or signing restrictive long-term contracts without performance guarantees.
What metrics matter most?
Leads, conversions, quality traffic, and not just keyword rankings.